Skip to content

UI/UX Review – Vertical Farm Application

Summary

This review covers the initial user experience (pre-login) and the main dashboard interface (post-login) of the Vertical Farm application. The application presents a complex, multi-pane interface for managing farm assets (Rooms, Racks, Trays, Sections, Spots). While functional for detailed asset selection post-login, the initial presentation and dashboard design have significant opportunities for improvement in terms of user-friendliness, visual appeal, and information hierarchy.

Specific User Query Response

Regarding the initial page view (pre-login):

  • Is it normal to see all of these panes? No, it is not conventional or advisable to display a complex, data-driven interface with multiple selection panes (Rooms, Racks, etc.) to users before they log in. This approach can be overwhelming for new users and exposes internal application structure unnecessarily.
  • Should all these panes only be accessible after login? Yes, absolutely. This type of detailed operational interface is core application functionality and should only be accessible to authenticated users.
  • What would be beautiful to see?
    • New User: A dedicated landing page that clearly communicates the app's value. This should include engaging visuals (e.g., a high-quality image of a vertical farm), a concise value proposition (e.g., "Smart Management for Your Vertical Farm"), clear calls to action ("Sign Up," "Learn More"), and perhaps a brief feature overview or social proof.
    • Returning User: A clean, straightforward login page. If 'remember me' is active, redirecting to their personalized dashboard upon arrival would be ideal.

Highlights ✅

  • Structured Navigation (Post-Login): The multi-pane layout (Rooms, Racks, Trays, Sections, Spots) provides a clear, albeit dense, hierarchical way to navigate and select specific farm assets once the user is familiar with the system.
  • Clear Typography: Text elements are generally legible.

Issues Found ⚠️

  • Page: Initial Landing Page (Pre-Login)

    • Issue: Displays a complex, data-oriented interface (asset selection panes) immediately, without any introduction or login prompt.
    • Impact: Highly confusing for new users, potentially overwhelming, and lacks a welcoming or informative experience. Poor first impression.
    • Recommendation: Replace with a dedicated landing page for new users (explaining the app's value and offering sign-up/learn more options) and a clear login path for returning users.

  • Page: Dashboard (Post-Login)

    • Issue: Information overload due to all five asset hierarchy panes being visible by default. The main 'Cultivation Data' area is underutilized, showing only a welcome message initially.
    • Impact: Can make the interface feel cluttered and difficult to scan. The dashboard doesn't provide an immediate overview of key farm metrics or activities.
    • Recommendation: Simplify the default dashboard view. Consider featuring key performance indicators (KPIs), alerts, or a summary of recent activity. Asset navigation could be more progressive (e.g., selecting a Room reveals its Racks). The detailed pane view could be a separate 'Farm Explorer' section.

  • Page: General Interface (Post-Login)

    • Issue: Lack of strong visual hierarchy within the panes and minimal use of color for status or emphasis. Potential for small font sizes in panes to be an accessibility concern.
    • Impact: Can make the interface feel monotonous and important information may not stand out. Readability could be an issue for some users.
    • Recommendation: Improve visual hierarchy with better use of spacing, font weights, and color. Use color strategically for status indicators (alerts, warnings, nominal) and to highlight active selections. Ensure font sizes meet accessibility standards.

  • Interaction: Navigation Flow (Post-Login)

    • Issue: Potential lack of breadcrumbs to indicate the user's current position in the multi-level selection. No clear information on how to reset selections or navigate back up the hierarchy easily.
    • Impact: Users can get lost in the navigation. Inefficient interaction if resetting selections is cumbersome.
    • Recommendation: Implement clear breadcrumbs. Provide intuitive controls for clearing selections or moving up the hierarchy. Consider a global search/filter for larger setups.

Overall Recommendations 💡

  1. Redesign Pre-Login Experience: Create a welcoming landing page for new users and a distinct, easy-to-use login page/flow for all users.
  2. Reimagine the Dashboard: The post-login landing page should be a true dashboard offering insights and summaries (e.g., visual charts of environmental data, alerts, task lists) rather than just asset selection panes.
  3. Progressive Disclosure for Navigation: Instead of showing all five levels of asset hierarchy at once, allow users to drill down (e.g., click a Room to see its Racks). This simplifies the interface.
  4. Enhance Visual Design & Accessibility: Introduce a more engaging color palette, use color for status and emphasis, ensure accessible font sizes and contrasts, and consider using icons for better visual communication.
  5. Improve Interaction Cues: Ensure clear selected states, hover effects, and loading indicators. Add breadcrumbs for multi-level navigation.
  6. Brand Consistency: While not explicitly detailed in the screenshots, ensure the UI aligns with any existing brand guidelines, style tokens, and component patterns. This includes logo placement, color usage, and typographic choices, especially on the proposed new landing page.

Next Steps

  • Prioritize Pre-Login Redesign: This is critical for first impressions and user onboarding.
  • User Research for Dashboard: Understand what information is most vital for users to see upon logging in to design an effective dashboard.
  • Accessibility Audit: Conduct a formal accessibility check (WCAG guidelines) for color contrast, keyboard navigation, and screen reader compatibility.
  • Iterative Design & Testing: Implement changes incrementally and gather user feedback.